Behind the Bread: What Makes Novel the Best Sandwich Shop in Rochester
Share
In the past year or so, Novel has grown quite a reputation as a thoughtfully curated and welcoming bookstore, but what passersby might not know is that the sandwich menu is equally incredible! With fresh, often locally sourced ingredients and expertly crafted flavor profiles, our sandwiches have quickly become a lunchtime favorite for Rochester locals.
But, as we all know, a sandwich is nothing without quality bread! Let’s slice into the details of our incredible selection.

Why You Should Grab Lunch in Rochester at a Locally Owned Spot?
The next time you’re looking for a lunch spot in Rochester, refrain from visiting the chain stores and fast food joints and consider supporting a local business instead! Putting your hard-earned money back into your community is the best way to strengthen your local economy. When you buy a sandwich at our Rochester bookstore, you can rest assured that, whether you’re buying the latest sports romance or grilled cheeses for the kids, the profits will benefit your neighbors and other local businesses.
The History of Novel
At Novel, Rachel may be in charge of curating the shelves, but it’s her husband, Elliott (and the other half of the co-owner duo), who crafts the artisanal sandwiches. With a long history of loving food, from washing dishes at his family’s café to attending culinary school, it was always a dream of his to open up a sandwich shop in Rochester.
Together, they dreamed up a hybrid store, working around the clock with friends and family to bring their ideal third space to life. It’s been a big hit on the block ever since!
What’s a Sandwich Without the Bread?

Don’t let the anti-carb propaganda sway you—without bread, whether you prefer whole wheat, rye, or a different variety, there’d be no sandwich! Bread provides actual structure to your sandwich, keeping fillings together and allowing you to hold it in one hand for easy, portable dining at lunch in Rochester.
Depending on the type and how it’s prepared, bread also provides the perfect textural contrast. Some slices give you that soft, pillowy feel, while others add a bit of crunch to each bite. The perfect bread for a sandwich depends greatly on the rest of your components, but it’s fun to try different pairings in the kitchen!
Many customers who grab lunch in Rochester forget that bread actually contributes to the overall taste profile. Depending on the grains used, the bread could add sweet, nutty, tangy, fermented, or yeasty vibes to your sub or panini.
Behind the Bread: CRUST
When it came time to create the sandwiches, they knew they’d need to find a high-quality and delicious bakery to supply fresh bread. That’s where CRUST came in.
Known in the local bakery scene as a beacon of artisanal excellence, CRUST has been baking breads, pastries, and desserts since 2012. In the years before opening, the founders traveled the continent in an attempt to gain as much knowledge on traditions and techniques as possible. Their baking arsenal grew with every trip, whether it was finding a source for quality ingredients or learning to master tasty flavors.
As a company, CRUST prioritizes quality and authenticity every step of the way. Between the intoxicating aroma of delicacies coming out of the oven, the friendly smiles behind the counter, and the innovative recipes, it’s no wonder CRUST has remained at the forefront of its field. Between the perfectly risen sourdough and timeless classic white, every loaf we get delivered is absolute perfection—stop by and experience it for yourself at lunchtime in Rochester!
How Do We Choose Which Bread to Use for Our Rochester Sandwiches?
When it comes to choosing which bread to use for a sandwich on the menu at our Rochester lunch spot, Elliott has a lot of elements to consider. Thanks to the time and care he puts into each recipe, every Rochester sandwich creation is unique!
Since they’re all served made-to-order and hot off the panini press, the bread will have to hold up well when grilled. The right bread will also complement the fillings. If it packs a savory punch, something cheesy and bright works wonderfully. If it’s rich and herbaceous, perhaps a sourdough is best. The right pairing is not always found right off the bat—the perfect combo is found through endless taste tests and trial and error.

Novel’s Staple Sandwich Menu:
- Roast Beef Chimichurri (on Tri-County Pepper bread)
- Turkey Caprese (on Sourdough)
- Italian (on City White)
- Mortadella (on Hammonton, depending on if we get it in)
- Vegetarian (on Sourdough)
- The Big Ham & Cheese (on Sourdough)
- Grilled Cheese (on Sourdough)
Does Novel Do Any Weekly Special Sandwiches in Rochester?
While most of the menu is set in stone, we do offer new sandwich specials at our Rochester shop. Taking inspiration from seasonally fresh ingredients and the world around us, Elliott makes sure to change the specials once a week. A few past favorites include The Ham n’ Jam, with chili fig jam and grilled pineapple, and The Rachel, loaded with homemade coleslaw and thousand island dressing.
Does Novel Offer a Gluten-Free Bread for Our Rochester Sandwiches?
At the moment, Novel does not carry a gluten-free bread option. Since our Rochester sandwiches are grilled on a shared panini press, there is no way to avoid cross-contamination during lunch in Rochester.
But if you’re celiac, don’t worry! You can still grab a coffee as you browse our indie bookstore.
When is Novel Open for Lunch in Rochester?
The kitchen at Novel is open from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM Tuesday through Saturday. The rest of the bookstore remains open until 6:00 PM, so if you’re mainly visiting Rochester for lunch, make sure you plan ahead and arrive within the allotted dining time frame.
What Else We Carry from CRUST:

Not in the mood for a full sandwich in Rochester? Check out our rotating selection of baked goods from CRUST, which may include:
- Scones
- Pies
- Croissants
- Cookies
- Donuts
We can hear your stomach grumbling from here! Stop by Novel to experience our tasty lunch options in Rochester for yourself. You may just find your next read while you’re at it.